Like Autobiography of Red, the only other work I have read by Carson, Decreation was read devoured in just a few days; and, like Autobiography of Red, Carson’s most recent collection left me burning: upon finishing, I wanted nothing more than to turn back to the first page and start over. I restrained myself, however, due to reading etiquette (which has only been broken once in the last few years with Nabokov’s Pale FIre, however I generally discount it considering this happened before I really formalized the rule of never reading the same author twice in a row, even if it is the same book).
My first wish whilst reading this collection, conceived just after completing the relatively straight-forward poems introducing the book, was that I was more intelligent, analytical, and in general a better reader. While the bulk of Autobiography of Red is fairly accessible, Decreation is rather intimidating. I finished it about a week ago and still feel that I only understand a fraction of it; and when I feel the need to read it again, I sincerely believe that it should be done more aggressively, armed with a small notebook and a pen. Those that approach reading lightly should cower before it, or simply throw it away in disgust; it is not for the half-interested.
But it is a beautiful thing. Erudition aside, there are so many striking lines, passages, images, and sentences, surely enough to satiate your thirst, but more likely enough to saturate (but not drown). A professor of classics by day, Carson of course draws on several Greek (and other) myths and stories, giving each a very modern pulse. One of the most intriguing works in the collection that is, what I would guess, the central work: Decreation: An Opera in Three Parts. Rather than explain it or describe it, I’ll simply post one of its many arias.
Aria of Brittle Failure Theory
[sung by Hephaistos lying on his bed amid debris of the trap, chorus tapdancing slowly around]
Chorus:
Brittle failure occurs
of course
when stress on a material exceeds its
tensile force
(so scientists say).
Brittle failure theory
should predict
when some quietly oozing volcano
will erupt
in a deadly pyroclastic way.
But with you Hephaistos it’s hard to know.
You’re strangely slow.
H:
My theory is
I could split my heart on the anvil
and put her inside
and weld it together again
then there she’d stay
till the end of time,
there she’d stay
in no one’s heart
but mine.
And I know
our love would grow
freer and brighter
with every stroke of the hammer.
Chorus:
Brittle failure theory may
in the end fail
to explain how true love can
ever avail
against forgery.
But with you Hephaistos it’s hard to know.
You get that strange glow.
H:
My theory is
I don’t care anymore about justice, injustice,
how they end,
how they start.
I just want to be clear
to be more and more clear
until finally
all you see
is the line
left by the cutting tool
in the heart,
not even
the heart.
For those of you adventurous enough, beauty-starved and thirsty for something that requires a great deal of thought, I couldn’t recommend this enough. It is another work by a great author that has so quickly elbowed her way into my list of favorites and shall remain there for a long time.